ChatFAI
#54 on the ranking
ChatFAI is a character-chat site that was briefly the unfiltered Character.AI, and the numbers say that moment has passed.
Read my full ChatFAI analysis →AI girlfriend sites side by side · Both tested first-hand · Data through September 2026
vs
I bought a membership on both and tested each for a month. What they offer, their measured numbers and what their users say, next to each other, with my verdict on each at the end.
The scoreboard
SpicyChat leads on 3 of the 4 figures that decide most choices.
In short
| What they offer | ||
|---|---|---|
| Free tier | ▲Yes | ▲Yes |
| Entry paid plan | Free | $4.95/mo |
| Adult content | Allowed on paid plans | Allowed on paid plans |
| Features |
|
|
| Best for | Users interested in creative character exploration beyond standard AI girlfriend formats | Budget-conscious users who want quality AI conversation and NSFW chat at the lowest possible price |
| Not for | Users primarily wanting a dedicated romantic companion, voice, image generation, or mobile access | Anyone who wants voice interaction, image generation, or cross-session memory |
| Operator | Chatfai LLC (named on the Google Play listing; the site itself does not say) | NextDay AI |
| Pricing notes | Free tier available (roughly 500 messages/month across 4 characters). Paid plans start around $9.99/month, with a discounted annual plan averaging under $7/month, plus optional one-time message-credit top-ups. Browser-based access. | Named monthly tiers: Get A Taste ~$4.95-$5/mo, True Supporter ~$14/mo, I'm All In ~$24/mo, with roughly 17% off if billed annually. |
My take
Both give you a free tier, so you can try the chat on each before paying; expect message caps and few or no images until you upgrade.
| The numbers | ||
|---|---|---|
| Rank on this siteOn the combined data gathered for every site | #54 | ▲#15 |
| Google US rank, “ai girlfriend”DataForSEO ranked keywords, September 2026 | – | – |
| Tranco rank, all domainsAll-traffic rank among the top million domains | #1,443,913 | ▲#6,952 |
| Chrome UX tierGoogle Chrome UX Report | – | Top 5,000 |
| Search visits a month, worldwideDataForSEO estimate | 84,932 | ▲2,411,388 |
| Search visits a month, US | 20,007 | ▲677,277 |
| Brand searches a month, USGoogle Ads data via DataForSEO | 3,600 | ▲1,000,000 |
| Domain RatingDomain Rating by Ahrefs, out of 100 | 49 | ▲72 |
| Referring domains | 2,111 | ▲4,131 |
| Backlinks | 10,632 | ▲913,423 |
| Domain registered | December 2022 | May 2023 |
| Public record I read | 9 videos, 2 Reddit threads, 1 articles | 11 videos, 9 Reddit threads, 4 articles |
The better value in each row is marked in green. Search visits and brand searches are DataForSEO estimates; Tranco and Chrome UX tiers are ranks, not visit counts.
My take
None of these ranks in the tracked positions for "ai girlfriend", so their places on this site come from all-traffic rank, and their visitors arrive by name, by ads or from app stores rather than from the category search. On size, SpicyChat is the busier site: 2,411,388 search visits a month worldwide, more than 30 times what ChatFAI gets (84,932). These are estimates of visits from Google only, so a site with apps or ads can be bigger than this shows. Brand searches are the loyalty line: 1,000,000 people a month type SpicyChat's name, against 3,600 for ChatFAI. A name people type on purpose is a site they come back to; a site with lots of visits and few brand searches is living on rankings it could lose. SpicyChat's Domain Rating of 72 against 49 means far more sites link to it, which is what keeps rankings stable; the weaker link profile is the one more likely to move, up or down, when Google reshuffles. ChatFAI is the older domain (2022 against 2023), which counts for something in a category where sites close without notice.
| Feature by feature | ||
|---|---|---|
| Chat and roleplay | Users mixedMy test: Agree | Users positiveMy test: Agree |
| Memory | Users negativeMy test: Disagree | – |
| Characters and customisation | Users positiveMy test: Agree | – |
| Group chats | Users mixedMy test: Partly disagree | – |
| Image generation | Users negativeMy test: Agree | – |
| Voice messages | Users negativeMy test: Agree | – |
| Free tier | Users negativeMy test: Agree | – |
| Price and message credits | Users mixedMy test: Partly disagree | – |
| Privacy and billing | Users mixedMy test: Agree | Users mixedMy test: Agree |
| Moderation and content rules | Users mixedMy test: Agree | – |
| Memory and lorebooks | – | Users mixedMy test: Partly disagree |
| Models | – | Users mixedMy test: Agree |
| Images and voice | – | Users negativeMy test: Disagree |
| Characters and the creator community | – | Users positiveMy test: Agree |
| Free tier and queues | – | Users positiveMy test: Agree |
| Price and no tokens | – | Users positiveMy test: Agree |
| Age verification and filters | – | Users mixedMy test: Agree |
| Support and moderation | – | Users positiveMy test: Agree |
“Users” is the balance of the YouTube reviews, Reddit threads and articles read for each brand page; “my test” is whether my own month on the site agreed with them.
My take
Users are happier with SpicyChat: 5 of its 10 features come out positive, against ChatFAI's 1 of 10, with 4 features where the complaints win. SpicyChat gets it on chat and roleplay. My own month did not always match the crowd: I disagreed with users on 3 points for ChatFAI and 2 points for SpicyChat, and each disagreement is spelled out on the brand page.
My verdict on each
ChatFAI
#54 on the ranking
ChatFAI is a character-chat site that was briefly the unfiltered Character.AI, and the numbers say that moment has passed.
Read my full ChatFAI analysis →SpicyChat
#15 on the ranking
SpicyChat is the free, no-tokens roleplay site, and a month with it convinced me that is enough to be second in the category.
Read my full SpicyChat analysis →More comparisons
Written by Hunter Gray, Founder, Owner & Writer. Every figure is from the two brand pages and refreshes monthly. ChatFAI and SpicyChat are two of the sites in my best AI girlfriend ranking, where the whole category is ordered on the same data.